Why bother writing about music?
The title of this post explains why I haven't had much output at Soundslope lately.
I'm not sure exactly what the point is. I like to consider myself an advocate of music, both broadly and in relation that pesky music we call jazz, but I'm no longer sure what is accomplished by writing about it.
I never end up feeling like I've hit the target or attained anything in the way of accurately describing music.
I also want to avoid shilling too much for music I like to the point that it dilutes my overall message and focus. I have no interest in delving into the narcissistic world of thumbs up and down, x number of stars, what I call the journalistic circle jerk.
Ultimately music is the most powerful commentary on music. Musicians absorb past and present influence, their own experiences, and myriad consciousness into their craft.
They music about music (amongst other things), and if you want to really understand the music, the best thing to do is to listen to it.
I understand that it can be difficult to navigate and find out about what to listen to, which is my only motivation in writing. To turn people on to what I hear as good music. I'm just not convinced any more that I was accomplishing that in any real sense.
I wish there was some way to track actual purchases of music based on my reviews, that might provide some nice motivation. These days I'd be more likely to find out that people had illegally downloaded music I wrote about, which would just depress me further.
I'm also the kind of writer who approaches all subjects with the underlying question of "who cares what I think?" running at all times. If it doesn't pass the BS test I won't bother. Frankly, of late, I haven't felt compelled to put myself through that wringer.
And so Soundslope is more or less dormant these days. If you enjoy what I write I encourage you to check in now and then and keep me on your RSS feeds, but the truth is that I'm not sure if or when I'll be a reliable source of up to date reviews and information.
So life goes on: more time to sit on the cushion!
Thanks to everyone for reading.
Jeeze Dan, that's a drag you are down in the dumps.
Here's why I write about music, mainly to describe it rather than to evaluate it. One problem with Jazz is that it is still in some schizoid limbo compared with its counterparts, 'classical' and folkloric.
Both of those have competent musicologists writing useful stuff to identify the notable elements of an idiom.
For example, get nearly any Nonesuch Explorer cd from some part of the world you are curious about and check the wealth of cool detail, explanations of its role in its home culture, photo's of cool instruments, maybe a few notation bars of melody and so on.
The same tends true in nearly any decent classical disc as if this matters. In jazz you get crappy glib liner notes by some flabby tool that communicate very little as a rule.
So useful quasi musicological descriptions are very helpful. We just have a jazz writership made up of people who came from either boiler plate marketing copy backgrounds or sports writing where everything is pumped superlatives or faux stats.
If you haven't read it, take some time to read A Sand County Almanac by Aldo Leopold and note the amazing way he just describes the living world before his eyes. Then just apply that sort of approach to describing music and it becomes fun again.
Maybe prepare by getting up before daybreak of a summers country day and heading out with some coffee and a notepad and just describe the arrival of thrush noise, bug buzz and any other odd marvels that might happen, a deer crew going home, a grouse pumping air or what have you.
It's a thought anyway.
- reply
Submitted by Chris Rich (not verified) on Mon, 06/29/2009 - 6:52pm.Hi Chris,
Thanks for your thoughts, I appreciate it.
I'm sure I'll get back to the point of wanting to write more about the music. I seem to go in cycles with this kind of thing and I'm at the low point of the ebb and flow.
I have read Leopold's Sand County Almanac although it's probably been a good 10 years since I did. Maybe I will revisit it.
Thanks again for writing,
Dan
- reply
Submitted by Daniel Melnick on Tue, 06/30/2009 - 2:47pm.